Korean Journal of Acupuncture

Table. 2.

Table. 2.

Intervention used in articles for neurogenic bladder

First author (year) Intervention

Acupuncture Electroacupuncture Pharmacopuncture Herbal medicine Moxibustion Etc.
Park (2015)8) TE3, TE2, GB41, BL66, BL40, BL67, LI1, ST36
F: 1 time/day, R: 15 min, N: 79
BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34 (Day 11∼57)→CV3, CV4 (58∼79)
F: 1 time/day, R: 15 min, N: 69 Mode: 3 Hz
None Palmulgunja-tang (Day 1∼32)
Sahyangsohab-won (1∼32)
Gamiboheo-tang (33∼57)
Cheongsimyeonja-eum (57∼79)
Singigu: CV4
F: 1 time/day, N: 79
None
Song (2016)9) CV3, BL22, BL28, SP9 F: 1 time/day, R: 20 min, N: 84 BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34 (Day 36∼84)
F: 1 time/day, R: 20 min, N: 49 Model: ES-160, Mode: 2 Hz
Sweet bee venom: BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34 (Day 36∼84)
F: 1 time/day, N: 49
D: 0.5 cc
Boyanghwano-tang, Mangeum-tang, Boik-tang, Saengmaegikgi-tang
Uchasingi-hwan (Day 30∼84)
None None
Park (2005)10) BL25, BL26, BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34 [at A.M.]
F: 1 time/day, R: 20/min, N: 62 ST28, LR3, PC6, ST36, SP6 [at P.M.]
F: 1 time/day, R: 20 min, N: 62
CV1, CV4, LI4, LR3 [at P.M.]
F: 1 time/day, R: 20 min, N: 62
Model: New pointer SJ 106
Mode: DC-9V, 11.8 mA, 32 Hz, 3∼4 intensity
None Yungmijihwang-tang (Day 1∼12, 19∼23),
Samgi-tang (13∼18, 24∼26, 37∼62),
Bojungikgi-tang (27∼36)
Extract Oryeong-san (1∼62)
Bamboo giant moxa: CV4, CV8, CV12
F: 1 time/day
N: 62
None
Kim (2005)11) CV2, CV3, CV4, CV6, SP6, SP9
F: 1 time/day, R: 20 min, N: 17
CV1, BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34
F: 1 time/day, R: 20 min, N: 17
Model: New pointer SJ 106
Mode: DC-9V, 11.8 mA, 32 Hz, 3∼4 intensity
Bee venom: CV4, BL25, BL26
F: 1 time/day, N: 17
D: 0.2∼1.0 cc
Daebuncheong-eum (Day 1∼17),
Extract Oryeong-san (Day 1∼17)
Indirect moxa: CV3, CV4, CV6, BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34
F: 1 time/day, N: 17
Physical therapy: Hot pack (PRN), ICT (F: 6 times/week)
Crede/Valsalva,
Dry/Wet cupping (PRN)
Jang (2012)12) CV4, CV6, SP6, SP9, LR3, BL66, GV20
F, R, N are unspecified
None Hwangryunhaedok-tang: points are unspecified
F: 1 time/day, N: 39
Gijeh-wan (Day 1∼13),
Oryeong-san (1∼13)
Giant moxa: CV8
F: 3 times/day, N: 39
None
Lim (2003)16) CV6, SP6, SP9, BL23, KI10 (Day 1∼28)→ CV2, SP6, SP9, LR1 (29∼58)
F: 1 time/2 days R: 25 min, N: 29
None Bee venom: CV4, CV6 (Day 44∼58)
F: 1 time/2 days
N: 7
D: 0.1∼0.5 cc
Danggwisu-san (Day 1∼11) None None
Ahn (2002)18) CV3, CV4, CV6, SP6, SP9, BL23, BL28, BL67, LR3, LR8
F: 2 times/day, N: 148
None None Yungmijihwang-tang (Day 1∼74) Indirect moxa: CV3, CV4, CV6
F: 3 times/day, N: 222
Dry cupping
F: 1 time/day
Kim (2006)19) Dong-Qi Acupuncture: Gyeonjung, Mokwa, Mokji, Sugeum, Sutong, Chasam (Day 1∼71)→Singwan, Jihwang, inhwang, sahwasang (72∼113)
F: 6 times/week, R: 20 min, N: 96
None None Yungmijihwang-tang, Dokwaljihwang-tang, Hyeongbangjihwang-tang: Durations are not specified None Physical therapy: TENS (F: 1 time/day),
Crede/Valsalva,
Dry cupping
F: 1 time/day
Venesection
F: 1 time/2 Day
Lee (2008)20) 1. None
2. None
3. None
1. BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34
2. BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34
3. BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34
F: 1 time/day, R: 20 min
N: 1 (10), 2 (9), 3 (11)
Model: PG-6, Mode: 2 Hz
1. None
2. None
3. None
1. Jinmu-tang (Day 1∼10)
2. Yeoldahanso-tang (Day 1∼9)
3. Samgi-tang (Day 1∼7), Jeongjeongamiijin-tang (8∼11)
1. Singigu: CV4, F: 1 time/day, N: 10
2. None
3. Direct moxa: CV3, CV4, CV6 F: 1 time/day, N: 11
1. None
2. None
3. Medication: Harnal-D, 1T, qd Hinecol, 1T, tid
Kim (2008)21) Acupoint of Conception Vessel at lower abdominal region [at A.M.] F: 1 time/day, R: 15 min, N : 21 BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34 [at P.M.]
F: 5 time/week, R: 15 min, N: 15
Mode: unspecified
None Uchasingi-hwan (Day 1∼21) Indirect moxa: CV4 F: 2 times/day, N: 42 Medication: Terazosin, 1T, qd hs
Yoon (2009)22) None BL31, BL32, BL33, BL34 (Day 2∼11)
F: 1 time/day, R: 20 min, N: 10
Mode: 2 Hz
None Unspecified None None
Oh (2018)23) LI1, LI4, LI11, ST36, LR1, SP1, GB12, GV20, GV26
F: 1 time/day, R: 20 min, N: 60
None None Dokwaljihwang-tang (Day 1∼16)
Yanggyeoksanhwa-tang (Day 17∼60)
Direct moxa: CV3, CV4, CV6
F: 3 times/day, N: 180
None

F : frequency of treatment, D : injection dose, ICT : interferential current therapy, N : number of treatment, PRN : pro re nata, R : retaining time, TENS : transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation.

Korean J Acupunct 2021;38:111-21 https://doi.org/10.14406/acu.2021.019
© 2021 Korean J Acupunct